Motorola SLVR MP3 Bit Rate Limitations

This evening I spent some time figuring out how to use iTunes in my new cell phone - the Motorola SLVR L7. And some might say "Uh... figure out how to use iTunes? And you're a geek??"

Yes, that's how I felt as well. I kept trying to add songs to the phone, and iTunes would respond with this cryptic message: "Some of the songs were not copied to the mobile phone... because they cannot be played". What? Why not? I kept scratching my head trying to figure out, "Why? What is wrong with these songs? They work everywhere else... and it's not a DRM issue."

I rip all my songs at 320k, variable bit rate, highest quality. I have no trouble playing them on my Mac, on my PCs, or on my iPod. But the Motorola SLVR apparently has some sort of bit-rate limit. What is the limit? I don't know. I searched everywhere, and could not find any mention of any such limit anywhere.

So, I began trial and error. 320k without variable bit rate - nope. 128k - yes. 256k? Nope. 192k? Yes. But... what about all the music I already have, which is all at 320k VBR?

After an hour of googling, I found mention of a new "Phone" tab that gets added to the iTunes preferences panel (or dialog, in Windows speak). Then I figured out that the phone has to be physically connected to get this tab to show up. Then I studied the tab, and checked an item that says "Convert higher bit rate songs to 128kbps AAC". I checked this - and problem solved.

Now iTunes, when the phone is connected, converts my songs to a lower-bit rate and then copies them to the phone. Needless to say, this takes forever, added on top of the already long time it takes for the SLVR to sync up to the computer in the first place (apparently, it's a USB 1.1 device).

This is the latest and greatest in the "non-helpful error message" category. Would it kill Apple to create an error message that tells me the problem - like "This phone only supports bit rates up to 128K. Please change the settings in the Phone section of iTunes preferences".

Also... nowhere (or at least nowhere that I can find) on Motorola or Apple's site is any mention made of this bit-rate limitation. It just says "Plays MP3s". Again, would it kill them to add a statement "Mp3s up to 128k bit rate", or something to that effect?

I hate it when I have to spend hours figuring out something that the people who created this could have easily written down. I expect better from Apple. And why is the phone limited in this way? Every iPod I've owned can play whatever bit rate is thrown at it.

Having vented all of that, I will say that now that I've got that all figured out, it works fairly well. Awfully complicated to keep track of, however.

Leave a comment


Recent Entries

  • Diary of a Wimpy Kid

    Diary of a Wimpy Kid (2007) by Jeff Kinney. Amulet Books, 218 pages. Diary of a Wimpy Kid: Rodrick Rules (2008) by Jeff Kinney....

  • President-Elect Barack Obama

    Frank and I had settled in for a long night of watching election returns. We had both arranged to take off work the day...

  • The Age of American Unreason

    The Age of American Unreason by Susan Jacoby (2008). Pantheon Books, 356 pages. Remember the term "Highbrow"? You don't hear that much anymore. Nor...

  • Early Voting in Florida

    Yesterday I spent 2 hours voting. Since I live in Florida, The State That Doesn't Know How to Hold An Election, I figured I...

  • The Big Bang Theory

    The Big Bang Theory. Mondays on CBS, 8:00pm ET/PT As a genre, the sitcom has seen better days. For the past four years, since...

  • MacBook Pro

    Apple MacBook Pro. 15" Display, 2.53 Ghz Core 2 Duo Processor, 4GB RAM, 320 GB Hard Drive. Since Apple moved to using Intel chips 3...

  • A Dream Transcription

    A few nights ago I woke up in the middle of the night, needing to use the bathroom. I was right in the middle of...

  • Monty Python's Life of Brian

    Monty Python's Life of Brian (1979). 83 minutes, Handmade Films / Sony Pictures. Directed by Terry Jones. It was the fall of 1979. I...

  • The 700 Billion Dollar Bailout

    It feels like it's 1990 all over again. Remember 1990? The Savings and Loan Crisis? It's arguably what cost George H.W. Bush the 1992 election....

  • Two Books I Didn't Finish

    Friends, family, and the very small number of readers of this blog who do not fall into either of those two categories know that I...