HD-DVD Combo Discs: Whose Bright Idea?

On Tuesday, I was in Circuit City picking up a new TivoHD machine. While I was there, I noticed that 300 was out on both high-def disc formats. I haven't seen 300, but have heard mostly good things, and figured it was worth a try.

I noticed it first on HD-DVD. Since I can play both formats, I'm pretty neutral when it comes to which one I pick up. Usually it's whatever one I find first. If I order, I choose Blu-Ray most of the time, unless the HD-DVD of the same film is significantly lower in price. Which, so far, has not happened much.

Now, Circuit City is not exactly a user-friendly store, but I did manage to find their high-def disc section. I found 300 in HD-DVD first - it was $34.99. That's over my $30 limit for a movie, so no go. Then I turned the corner and saw the Blu-Ray version of the same movie for $27.99. An easy choice! But why such a significant price difference? Aren't HD-DVDs supposed to be cheaper, as they can use the same mastering equipment?

Ah... but now I see what is different. 300 is being sold in the moronic dual format, the HD-DVD Combo Disc! This is an HD-DVD disc on one side, with a regular DVD on the other side. So, you get two versions for one! For the price of both combined! This is the stupidest idea I've seen since this idiotic format war began.

Why would anyone want both formats? If you can play HD-DVDs... you have no need at all for the regular DVD version. And if you don't have an HD-DVD player - then why would you pay $35.00 for a "combo" version when you can get the regular DVD version for $15.00? It makes no sense whatsoever. To make matters worse, the studios never offer a "non-combo" version. If you want the HD-DVD of the movie, it's the combo version or nothing.

And - HD-DVD combo format discs have a host of problems that normal HD-DVDs do not. For example, I bought Children of Men the day it came out. And, sure enough, it was a combo disc. I put it in my XBox360 HD-DVD drive... and nothing. It just spun around and never loaded. So, I sent it back to Amazon for a replacement. A week or so later, I got a replacement copy - which also did not work. Finally, after 3 weeks, I got a copy that worked.

Come to find out, the reason it took so many tries... was that apparently there's a problem when making these combo discs. Basically, they glue a regular DVD onto the back of an HD-DVD. And apparently, sometimes this gluing process screws up the HD side, and renders it unplayable. Had Universal simply made it a regular HD-DVD, there would have been no problems.

So, let's sum up:

  • HD-DVD combo Discs costs more than regular, plain HD-DVD discs.
  • You get a extra side that you will never play, and which is duplicate of the side you actually want.
  • The discs have a higher failure rate than normal HD-DVDs

What idiot thought this up? And how long before these go the way of the dinosaur? I cannot for the life of me understand why the backers of HD-DVD continue to put out these expensive lemons that no one wants. If they want HD-DVD to survive (and/or "win"), drop the combo concept. Now.

1 Comment

I would have to say that the dual format is a good idea, IF it didn't cost more.

Right now, most people do not have an HD DVD player. Therefore, if the owner of the disc decides to bring the movie over to a firends house or loan it out, it allows it to be played whether that person has HD capabilities or not.

But, once more, they should not charge so much for them. It would be a huge boost in my eyes for HD DVD over Blu Ray if they offered this extra as a free bonus.

Leave a comment


Recent Entries

  • Diary of a Wimpy Kid

    Diary of a Wimpy Kid (2007) by Jeff Kinney. Amulet Books, 218 pages. Diary of a Wimpy Kid: Rodrick Rules (2008) by Jeff Kinney....

  • President-Elect Barack Obama

    Frank and I had settled in for a long night of watching election returns. We had both arranged to take off work the day...

  • The Age of American Unreason

    The Age of American Unreason by Susan Jacoby (2008). Pantheon Books, 356 pages. Remember the term "Highbrow"? You don't hear that much anymore. Nor...

  • Early Voting in Florida

    Yesterday I spent 2 hours voting. Since I live in Florida, The State That Doesn't Know How to Hold An Election, I figured I...

  • The Big Bang Theory

    The Big Bang Theory. Mondays on CBS, 8:00pm ET/PT As a genre, the sitcom has seen better days. For the past four years, since...

  • MacBook Pro

    Apple MacBook Pro. 15" Display, 2.53 Ghz Core 2 Duo Processor, 4GB RAM, 320 GB Hard Drive. Since Apple moved to using Intel chips 3...

  • A Dream Transcription

    A few nights ago I woke up in the middle of the night, needing to use the bathroom. I was right in the middle of...

  • Monty Python's Life of Brian

    Monty Python's Life of Brian (1979). 83 minutes, Handmade Films / Sony Pictures. Directed by Terry Jones. It was the fall of 1979. I...

  • The 700 Billion Dollar Bailout

    It feels like it's 1990 all over again. Remember 1990? The Savings and Loan Crisis? It's arguably what cost George H.W. Bush the 1992 election....

  • Two Books I Didn't Finish

    Friends, family, and the very small number of readers of this blog who do not fall into either of those two categories know that I...